2025 St. Genesius Award for Outstanding Musical, Mama Mia!
2025 Award for Outstanding Supporting Actress, Sofia Fink (Mama Mia!)
2025 Award for Outstanding Featured Actress, Marlowe Ferrie (Mama Mia!)
2025 Award for Outstanding Chorus, accepted by Caitlin Shea (Mama Mia!)
2025 Award for Outstanding Artistic Design, accepted by Patricia Schron (Mama Mia!)
2024 Award for Outstanding Featured Actress, Sofia Fink (Once Upon A Mattress)
2022 Award for Outstanding Featured Actress, Lillian Meagher (Little Women)
2019 Award for Outstanding Leading Actress, Nicole Sutherland
(Little Shop of Horrors)
2019 Award for Outstanding Featured Actor, Christian Cespedes
(Little Shop of Horrors)
2018 St. Genesius Award for Outstanding Musical, Xanadu
2018 Award for Outstanding Leading Actress, Kayla McBratney (Xanadu)
2018 Award for Outstanding Supporting Actor, Jesse Martinelli (Xanadu)
2018 Award for Outstanding Featured Dancer, Ashley Abbruzzese (Xanadu)
2018 Award for Outstanding Choreography (Xanadu)
2017 St. Genesius Award for Outstanding Musical, Jesus Christ Superstar
2017 Award for Outstanding Supporting Actress, Analise Scarpaci
(Jesus Christ Superstar)
2017 Award for Outstanding Artistic Design (Jesus Christ Superstar)
2016 Award for Outstanding Leading Actor, Nick Gerrity (Pippin)
2015 Award for Outstanding Leading Actor, Nick Gerrity (Godspell)
2012 Award for Outstanding Artistic Design (Seussical)
